i don't think i can keep reading Idol fic anymore, you guys. It's the most problematic and enraging fandom i've ever read in. and i
want to love it, because, i mean, i do, i love Adam and Kris and all the Lamberts and all the Allens, and I love David and David, and I seriously believe that Ryan and Simon are actually legit neck-deep in some kind of epically great angsty semi-closeted love affair for the ages.
but oh my god i just. i cannot cope. i can't cope with the way fandom writes off Katy Allen, how they alternately ignore her, make her into a bitch, or make Kris's marriage into a total repressed lie, all in the name of justifying Kris/Adam. Or if they like her, they make her into this completely passive figure who has no problem whatsoever with loaning her husband out to Adam in the name of allowing him to experience the great gay love of his life. Like reducing her to a magical helper for the Kradam is any better. and it just, it KILLS ME. i find it so upsetting.
and, like, the thing is that i
love Kris/Adam, I love them as friends, I love them as lovers, I love them together or apart, I just LOVE THEM BOTH AND THINK THEY ARE WONDERFUL, so I want to read fic about them. But I
don't want to read fic about Kris and Adam that's not also about Kris and Katy! :( I want to read fic about Kris
and Adam
and Katy, like, the three of them coming to terms with what they each mean to each other, and I want to read fic about all the Allens and all the Lamberts as, like, this amazing wonderful community of friends, and just, I feel like that nobody but me cares about that. So I keep trying to read Kris/Adam and then it upsets me. Like seriously, even a few of the Shalott fics make me sad, it's the worst thing ever. :( And then I rant about it on delicious, and probably just make people feel bad and harsh everyone's squee and then feel like a giant dick, because obvs if the solution is 'if you don't like it, don't read it,' and i
don't like it, but I
could love it! and I want to love it!, and, and, look, it's just not that simple! :( :( :( :(
And then there's freaking David/Archie, and let me tell you I think I have gotten to the point where there genuinely
are no good Cook/Archuleta fics to be found in this fandom, like after you read through Shalott's and Celli's and Hoyden's (oh my god please write more :( ) and that one chick who just locked all her fic so I can't even link to it now wtf, everything turns into this GIANT CESS POOL OF SQUICK.
Like, i'm not exaggerating, every fic reads as a really creepy fantasy. Either the fantasy of older women who want to take David Archuleta's virginity, and so write him like he is in fact an extreme version of a 14-year-old virgin, or the fantasy of actual fifteen-year-old fic writers who want David Cook to take
their virginity, and so write David Cook like this extreme version of a mentor/caretaker who confesses his love for Archie over and over again in this rush of sentiment, as if talking about how much he loves Archie will magically erase all the squicky age issues that most fics in this ship are replete with. A love-lorn older brother-cum-father figure who says things like "I'll take care of you, baby," while he's taking a trembling Archie's manhood.
I just. I DO NOT THINK I CAN TAKE IT ANYMORE.
and aslfjdkfd;ssdsdlkjsjdkldsj i kind of am so intrigued and fascinated and in love with the fandom that could have been. I don't want to give up on it altogether, but OH MY GOD I JUST CANNOT D-FACE ANY HARDER.
D:____
(since a couple of you have been asking, my idol recs are
here. there aren't very many. :/ The longer list of fic I've read that I didn't like enough to rec, but liked enough to leave public, is
here. But there's also a lot of incoherent rage there directed at some of the glambert fics. read at your own risk.
IT'S NOT YOU, IDOL FANDOM, IT'S ME :( )